Copyright and Free Speech: Comparative and International Analyses
Jonathan Griffiths, Uma Suthersanen
Oxford University Press, 2005 - Law - 426 pages
Written by a team of leading scholars and practitioners in the fields of copyright and free speech, this work analyses the potential for interaction and conflict between the two rights. Free speech is the lifeblood of any democracy. As John Stuart Mill stated, "In government, perfect freedom of discussion in all its modes - speaking, writing, and printing - in law and in fact is the first requisite of good because the first condition of popular intelligence and mental progress." (Letter by John Stuart Mill, 18 March, 1840) Copyright, on the other hand, represent a property regime which protects human creativity as manifested in all types of expressions such as literary works, paintings and music. Both these notions, copyright and free speech, are united in the fact of their recognition as fundamental freedoms of all individuals within the national, regional and international framework of human rights. However, the rights are also antithetical in nature, giving rise to bothpolitical and jurisprudential tensions. These tensions have become recently accentuated by the advent of legislative developments. Both in the United States and within the European Union, legal commentators argue that recent copyright legislation has paid insufficient regard to free speech. This concern is underlined by the series of First Amendment challenges that have been brought against the United States Digital Millennium Copyright Act. The recent causes celebres not only highlight theantagonistic relationship between copyright and free speech but also prominently depict the potential conflict between public and private interests in information - the Dead Sea Scrolls decision (Israel), the Wind Done Gone, Eldred and DeCSS cases (United States) and the Hyde Park v Yelland and Ashdown v Telegraph Group (United Kingdom). A further query which requires attention is the impact of the growing significance of international copyright law for the developing world. The raised profile of these conflicts has resulted in an increasing amount of attention from academe and the legal profession. Some of the authors of this volume have made influential contributions and are directly involved, both legally and politically, in the debate. There has, however, been no sustained study of the conflict across a variety of different jurisdictions. This book addresses the copyright/free speech relationship within a comparative and international legal framework. Moreover, the key questions regarding access to information and the digital challenges are addressed from both theoretical and practical perspectives.
What people are saying - Write a review
We haven't found any reviews in the usual places.
List of Contributors
Tables of Cases
Canadian Copyright Law and Its Charters
30 other sections not shown
2nd Cir Amendment scrutiny applied Apps 2nd Cir argued argument artistic Australian Berne Convention breach of confidence CDPA claim claimant common law concerns conflict constitutional context copy Copyright Act copyright and free copyright infringement copyright law copyright owner copyright protection corporations Court of Appeal creative Ct of Apps cultural database database right decision derogatory treatment DMCA doctrine ECHR economic Eldred example F 2d F 3d fact fair dealing fair dealing defence film free speech freedom of expression freedom of speech honour or reputation Human Rights Act Ibid injunction integrity right intellectual property rights interpretation issue limited media and entertainment moral rights parody political principles provisions public interest defence published recognized restrictions right to freedom scope social Soviet Suntrust Bank Supreme Court Telegraph Group tion TRIPs Agreement United Kingdom Wind Done Gone WIPO Copyright Treaty