Purgatory: The Logic of Total Transformation

Front Cover
Oxford University Press, USA, 2012 - Religion - 211 pages
2 Reviews
Jerry L. Walls, the author of books on hell and heaven, completes his tour of the afterlife with a philosophical and theological exploration and defense of purgatory, the traditional teaching that most Christians require a period of postmortem cleansing and purging of their sinful dispositions and imperfections before they will be fully made ready for heaven. He examines Protestant objections to the doctrine and shows that the doctrine of purgatory has been construed in different ways, some of which are fully compatible with Protestant theology. In particular, while purgatory has often been understood as matter of punishment in order to make satisfaction for sins that have not been fully remitted, it can also be seen as the completion of the sanctification process, an account of the doctrine that is fully consistent with the Protestant doctrine of justification by faith. Purgatory assumes not only continuity of personal identity but also gradual moral and spiritual growth between death and resurrection. Different theories of personal identity are examined and assessed in light of these assumptions. Walls also shows that the traditional doctrine of purgatory is not understood as a second chance for salvation, but goes on to argue that it should be modified to allow for postmortem repentance. He concludes with an examination of C.S. Lewis's writings on purgatory, and suggests that Lewis can be a model for evangelicals and other Protestants to engage the doctrine of purgatory in a way that is true to their theology.

What people are saying - Write a review

User Review  - Bruce Kohfield - Christianbook.com

All his conclusions are mere inferences including those he drew from C. S. Lewis. It is no wonder that the work does not have a scripture index. His entire work is his own opinionating something that ... Read full review

A Valiant, Well-Written Effort

User Review  - Jake - Christianbook.com

I’m a big Jerry Walls fan. I think it’s a shame he hasn’t gotten more recognition for his ability to produce work that is both scholarly and accessible to the educated layman. He’s forceful, yet ... Read full review


1 A Short History of Purgatory
2 Protestant Objections and Alternatives to Purgatory
3 Models of Purgatory
4 Personal Identity Time and Purgatory
5 Purgatory and Theories of a Second Chance
6 C S Lewis and the Prospect of Mere Purgatory
7 Looking Forward by Looking Back

Other editions - View all

Common terms and phrases

About the author (2012)

Jerry L. Walls has served as a Research Fellow in the Center for Philosophy of Religion at Notre Dame. He is the author of a trilogy on the afterlife, the first two volumes of which are Hell: The Logic of Damnation and Heaven: The Logic of Eternal Joy. He is also the editor of The Oxford Handbook of Eschatology.

Bibliographic information