Terror and LiberalismBerman puts his leftist credentials (he's a member of the editorial board of Dissent) on the line by critiquing the left while presenting a liberal rationale for the war on terror, joining a discourse that has been dominated by conservatives. The most original aspect of his analysis is to categorize Islamism as a totalitarian reaction against Western liberalism in a class with Nazism and communism; drawing on the ideas of Camus in The Rebel, Berman delineates how all three movements descended from utopian visions (in the case of Islamism, the restoration of a pure seventh-century Islam) into irrational cults of death. He illustrates this progression through a nuanced analysis of the writings of a leading Islamist thinker, Sayyid Qutb, ending with some chilling quotations from other Islamists, e.g., "History does not write its lines except with blood," the blood being that of Islam's martyrs (such as suicide bombers) as well as of their enemies, Zionists and Crusaders (i.e., Jews and Christians). Berman then launches into his most provocative chapter, and the one he will probably be most criticized for in politically correct journals: a scathing attack on leftist intellectuals, such as Noam Chomsky, who have applauded terrorism and tried to explain it as a rational response to oppression. Berman exhorts readers to accept that, on the contrary, Islamism is a "pathological mass political movement" that is "drunk on the idea of slaughter." A former MacArthur fellow and a contributing editor to the New Republic, Berman offers an argument that will be welcomed by disaffected progressives looking for a new analysis of today's world. |
Other editions - View all
Common terms and phrases
achievements Afghan Afghanistan Al Qaeda American anti-war Socialists Arab arguments attacks Baath Blum Bolsheviks bomb Bush the Elder Bush's Caliphate Camus Chomsky Chomsky's Christian Communist countries cultural death democratic doctrine Egypt enemies Europe European Fascists forces freedom French Galleani genocide goal going Hitler human imagine impulse intellectuals invasion Iraq Iraqi Islam Islamism's Islamist Islamist movement Israel Israeli Jewish Jews jihad killed Koran Laden leaders left-wing liberal civilization liberal democracy liberal ideas liberal society look Luigi Galleani mass movements military modern moral Muhammad murder Muslim Brotherhood Muslim world nationalist Nazis Nazism Nixon Palestinian philosophical Qaeda Qur'an Qutb's radical Ramadan rebellion religion revolution revolutionary Saddam Saudi Arabia Sayyid Qutb seemed shariah social solidarity Soviet spirit suicide terror Surah Taliban Tariq Ramadan Terror and Liberalism terrorists theories thing tion took totalitarian totalitarian movements United vanguard wanted Western writers wrote Zionism