Smoke Signals for the Gods: Ancient Greek Sacrifice from the Archaic Through Roman Periods
Animal sacrifice has been critical to the study of ancient Mediterranean religions since the eighteenth century. More recently, two leading views on sacrifice have dominated the subject: the psychological approach of Walter Burkert and the sociological one by Jean-Pierre Vernant and Marcel Detienne. These two perspectives have argued that the main feature of sacrifice is allaying feelings of guilt at the slaughter of sacrificial animals. However, both approaches leave little room for the role of the priests and the gods they hope to communicate with. Nor do they allow for comparison between animal sacrifice and other oblations offered to the gods. F. S. Naiden redresses the omission of these salient features to show that, far from being an attempt to assuage guilt or achieve solidarity, animal sacrifice is an attempt to make contact with a divine being, and that it is so important for—and perceived to be so risky for—the worshippers that it becomes subject to regulations of unequaled extent and complexity. Sacrificial priests are the most closely regulated of all Greek officials, and sacrifice itself is the most closely regulated public business. All this anxiety and effort invites some explanation, yet to date scholars have paid little attention to these regulations. Smoke Signals for the Gods addresses these, while drawing on recent work on Greek sacred law and Greek religious terminology. Furthermore, it seek to explain how mistaken views of sacrifice and animals arose, and traces them farther into the past, often back to early Christianity. Drawing on a wealth of sources, this book provides a complete picture of ancient animal sacrifice.
What people are saying - Write a review
We haven't found any reviews in the usual places.
1 The Invention of a Ritual
2 Venues and Offerings
3 Prayers and Answers
4 A God Says No
5 Rules Rewards and Experts
6 Markets and Messes
7 A Detective Story
8 The Demise of a Ritual
Other editions - View all
accept Achaeans acts of sacriﬁce Aeschines Aeschylus altar ancient animal sacriﬁce Apollo Aristophanes Artemis Asclepius Athenian Athens Burkert cattle celebrant century BCE Christ Christian civic Classical conﬁrms Delphi Dionysus divine Durkheim entrails example extispicy feast festival FGrH ﬁce ﬁg ﬁgure ﬁnd ﬁne ﬁre ﬁrst god’s goddess gods Greek sacriﬁce Hebrew Hellenistic hepatoscopy Heracles Herodotus Hiera Kala Homer honor human sacriﬁce Iliad implies incense inscription killing kilograms kind libations LSAM LSCG Lucianus magistrates meal meat Meuli Odysseus ofﬁcials ofsacriﬁce ofthe ofthis oracle pagan Panathenaea Paus Pausanias performed Philostr pigs Plutarch polis portion Poseidon prayer priestess priests puriﬁcation rejection religion request response rite ritual Robertson Smith sacred sacri sacriﬁce on behalf sacriﬁcial animals says schol scholars SgIuIL sheep shrine slaughter slave sources Spartan sphagia Stengel Thucydides thusia tion Unstated vegetal offerings Vernant Vernant and Detienne victim worshippers writers X.An Xenophon Zeus