Reviews

User reviews

User Review - Flag as inappropriate

Bad, completely ignores the good parts of the books.

User Review - Flag as inappropriate

I applaud Wolf for seeing and understanding the many, many conflicts Rowling has created between already established cannon and whatever DH is. That said - his vitriolic ranting regarding Snape is idiotic - and more over he apparently fails to see that Dumbledore is consistent... in so much as he is an asshole. That said this book is interesting if only because I'm surprised it managed to get published... also there needs to be more thoughtful criticism of the HP books - what with them being pushed on impressionable minds. 

User Review - Flag as inappropriate

Broken Wand is a broken book that sadly got lost and forgotten in the regolith.

User Review - Flag as inappropriate

I can attempt to write a review of this book but it would mean wasting time I could spend reading. What I will say is this. Mr Wolf states that Rowling has not applied to the rules of her own universe and therefore, has ruin the integrity of her breakthrough masterpiece. But she has. She maintained her own laws time and time again but Wolf fails to see how these laws follow. It's as though he fails to understand the meaning of a word and how it is applied as its usage changes i.e. from noun to verb, and fails to follow how several plot points change with perspective, both ours and the characters. I also think he's trying to cash in.  

User Review - Flag as inappropriate

This is ridiculous! Haha! Surely this Guy only read it by his eyes not by his heart because all he saw is the mistakes , DUH! Come on!! Get a life and writing a book against a wonderful book like Harry Potter will not get you a life !!

All reviews - 5
5 stars - 0
4 stars - 0
3 stars - 0
1 star - 0

All reviews - 5
Editorial reviews - 0

All reviews - 5