Naturalism and Normativity

Mario De Caro, David Macarthur

Columbia University Press, Aug 11, 2010 - Philosophy - 376 pages

Normativity concerns what we ought to think or do and the evaluations we make. For example, we say that we ought to think consistently, we ought to keep our promises, or that Mozart is a better composer than Salieri. Yet what philosophical moral can we draw from the apparent absence of normativity in the scientific image of the world? For scientific naturalists, the moral is that the normative must be reduced to the nonnormative, while for nonnaturalists, the moral is that there must be a transcendent realm of norms.

Naturalism and Normativity engages with both sides of this debate. Essays explore philosophical options for understanding normativity in the space between scientific naturalism and Platonic supernaturalism. They articulate a liberal conception of philosophy that is neither reducible to the sciences nor completely independent of them yet one that maintains the right to call itself naturalism. Contributors think in new ways about the relations among the scientific worldview, our experience of norms and values, and our movements in the space of reason. Detailed discussions include the relationship between philosophy and science, physicalism and ontological pluralism, the realm of the ordinary, objectivity and subjectivity, truth and justification, and the liberal naturalisms of Donald Davidson, John Dewey, John McDowell, and Ludwig Wittgenstein.

Contents

• Science Naturalism and the Problem of Normativity: 1
• Conceptual and Historical Background: 21
• Philosophy and the Natural Sciences: 87
• Philosophy and the Human Sciences: 121
• MetaEthics and Normativity: 171
• Epistemology and Normativity: 227
• Naturalism and Human Nature: 287
• Contributors: 353
• Index: 357

About the author

Mario De Caro is associate professor of moral philosophy at University of Rome 3. He was a Fulbright Fellow at Harvard University and has taught at Tufts University. He has edited several anthologies, including, with David Macarthur, Philosophy in an Age of Science, two new volumes of essays by Hilary Putnam.

David Macarthur is senior lecturer in philosophy at the University of Sydney. He has published articles on skepticism, naturalism, neopragmatism, and Wittgenstein in leading journals, and, with Mario De Caro, is the editor of Naturalism in Question.

Bibliographic information

• Title: Naturalism and Normativity; Columbia Themes in Philosophy
• Editors: Mario De Caro, David Macarthur
• Publisher: Columbia University Press, 2010
• ISBN: 0231508875, 9780231508872
• Length: 376 pages
• Subjects: Philosophy / Ethics & Moral Philosophy; Philosophy / General; Philosophy / Movements / Realism; Science / Philosophy & Social Aspects