Critique of Pure Music
Why do we value music? Many people report that listening to music is one of life's most rewarding activities. In Critique of Pure Music, James O. Young seeks to explain why this is so. Formalists tell us that music is appreciated as pure, contentless form. On this view, listeners receive pleasure, or a pleasurable 'musical' emotion, when they explore the abstract patterns found in music. Music, formalists believe, does not arouse ordinary emotions such as joy, melancholy or fear, nor can it represent emotion or provide psychological insight. Young holds that formalists are wrong on all counts. Drawing upon the latest psychological research, he argues that music is expressive of emotion by resembling human expressive behaviour. By resembling human expressive behaviour, music is able to arouse ordinary emotions in listeners. This, in turn, makes possible the representation of emotion by music. The representation of emotion in music gives music the capacity to provide psychological insight-into the emotional lives of composers, and the emotional lives of individuals from a variety of times and places. And it is this capacity of music to provide psychological insight which explains a good deal of the value of music, both vocal and purely instrumental. Without it, music could not be experienced as profound. Philosophers, psychologists, musicians, musicologists, and music lovers will all find something of interest in this book.
What people are saying - Write a review
We haven't found any reviews in the usual places.
absolute music aesthetic emotion anti-formalist argument aria arousal of emotion aroused by music Bach’s believe that music Charles Avison cognitive significance composers composition da capo aria dissonant emotional contagion emotional responses emotions aroused Emotions in Music empirical evidence Eroica Symphony essay example experience of music expres expressive of emotion expressive of sadness feel formalists Handel’s hear heard as expressive human expressive behaviour human voice instrumental music Jerrold Levinson Journal of Aesthetics Kivy believes Kivy’s Krumhansl listening to music literature Malcolm Budd minor mode minor third mode music Mozart music arouses emotion music can arouse music expressive music represents emotion musical beauty musical emotion musical form one’s Osmin’s Rage painting performance Peter Kivy philosophers Philosophy of Music piece of music problem of opera profound psychological insight repetition representation resemblance theory responses to music sad music semantic sort Sound Sentiment Stephen Davies suggests Symphony test subjects tion view that music vocal