Interpreting a Classic: Demosthenes and His Ancient Commentators"Craig Gibson's Interpreting a Classic, starting from the papyrus fragments of Didymus on Demosthenes' Fourth Philippie, shows just how rewarding such recondite material can be. In Gibson's hands old-fashioned philological Wissenschaft becomes the high-level instrument for a beautifully argued step-by-step detective investigation (complete with translation and his own commentary) of one strand in the ancient academic pursuit of truth. As Gibson says, 'At stake was nothing less than the correct interpretation of a classic,' and this has clearly been his own guiding principle too. I cannot think of another book on so recherche a topic that so successfully combines meticulous scholarship with clarity, elegance of exposition, and an infectious enthusiasm for solving recalcitrant textual problems."—Peter Green, author of Alexander to Actium: The Historical Evolution of the Hellenistic Age "Desmosthenes was 'the orator,' in the view of subsequent writers, and reading his speeches was a part of education and culture for the rest of antiquity. But ancient readers, like modern ones, needed help to interpret and situate these speeches, which were intended for an audience who knew the issues, the circumstances, and the langauge. The result was commentaries, philological and historical, designed for readers of Hellenistic, Roman, and Byzantine times...In Interpreting a Classic, Gibson brings this material together and uses it to write the history of an important episode of reading the classics...Interpreting a Classic makes a significant contribution to our understanding of scholarship in antiquity and of ancient readers."—Kent Rigsby, Professor of Classics at Duke University and editor of the journal Greek, Roman, and Byzantine Studies |
Contents
Form and Transmission 13 51 | 13 |
Sources Agenda and Readership | 27 |
Didymus | 51 |
Commentary on Dem 911 and 13 | 77 |
Didymus Fragments in Harpocration | 137 |
Lexicon to Dem 23 P Berol inv 5008 | 157 |
Commentary on Dem 5 P Berol inv 21188 | 172 |
Lexicon to Dem 21 P Rain inv 7 | 190 |
Rhetorical Prologue and Commentary | 201 |
| 211 | |
Corcordance to the Translations | 225 |
| 231 | |
| 237 | |
| 249 | |
Other editions - View all
Interpreting a Classic: Demosthenes and His Ancient Commentators Craig A. Gibson Limited preview - 2002 |
Common terms and phrases
3b suppl Aeschines Amphictyonic Anaximenes ancient philological Androtion archonship argues Aristomedes Aristophanes Aristotle Athenaeus Athenian Constitution Athens Attic orators authors Berol classical cols commentaries on Demosthenes commentator decree Demos Demosthenes Dhmosqevnh Didy Didymus Didymus says Didymus’s Didymus’s commentaries Dilts Dinarchus Dionysius of Halicarnassus discussion Divdumo ejpi entry Eretria etymology excerption fourth-century frag fragments ga;r Greek Harpocration Harpocration’s Hermias Hermias of Atarneus historians interest interpretation Iphicrates k(ai king’s lemma lemmata lexicon lines MacDowell Macedonian Megarians Meidias mentioned mercenary Miltocythes modern mosthenes mus’s Naoumides notes o{ti Oreus Orgas Osborne ostracism ou{tw P.Berol.inv papyrus paraphrased passage peace peri Philip Philochorus Philochorus FGrH 328 philological and historical phrase probole Quintilian quotation readers reference restoration rhetorical scholarship scholia Sealey second century C.E. someone Spartan speech Stras suggests th;n Theopompus things tion to;n topics triremes tw`n Wade-Gery and Meritt Wankel word