The Thorn in the Chrysanthemum: Suicide and Economic Success in Modern Japan
Japanese society is frequently held up to the Western world as a model of harmony and efficiency, but the price it pays tends to be overlooked. In a searching analysis that will fascinate students and admirers of Japan as much as it will inform psychologists and suicidologists, Mamoru Iga discusses the precise nature of the “thorn in the chrysanthemum,” a thorn that may hurt both the Japanese and the outsider who conducts business with them.
The author, who was reared and educated in Japan, is uniquely qualified to interpret the value orientations of a society in which suicide is all too common. He finds that the traits leading to homogeneity and extreme adaptability in that society as a whole are the very traits that can produce painful reactions in the individual. Those traits are described as monism, groupism, authoritarianism, familism, and accommodationism, and together they comprise the Japanese “social character.”
Because the individual’s behavior is based on the images, assumptions, and ideas about the world that make up his or her culture, conformism in the individual is one major manifestation of Japan’s social character. In Japan, the need to fill one’s socially prescribed role may make it doubly difficult to think independently and creatively and to find solutions for the resulting stress.
Suicide notes and other personal documents reveal the painful cost of modern Japan’s success story, as the examination of individual suicides is related both to the theoretical framework of Durkheim’s types of suicide and to the sociological patterns that characterize suicide in Japan. It is in personal value orientations, however, that Iga finds the common ground between suicide and economic success.
American readers will find especially interesting the contrast between value orientations in Japan and in the United States. Nearly the opposite of the Japanese traits described above, American values of rationalism, individualism, competition, and change create their own problems. There is much to be learned from this expert analysis of the problem of suicide in Japan.
This title is part of UC Press's Voices Revived program, which commemorates University of California Press’s mission to seek out and cultivate the brightest minds and give them voice, reach, and impact. Drawing on a backlist dating to 1893, Voices Revived makes high-quality, peer-reviewed scholarship accessible once again using print-on-demand technology. This title was originally published in 1986.
What people are saying - Write a review
We haven't found any reviews in the usual places.
Other editions - View all
accepted According American appears aspects attempted attitude authoritarian became become behavior called cause committed suicide common concept concern contrast critical culture Dazai death dependent desire difference economic effective effort emphasis examination example expected factors fear feel females force future goal highly human ideal ideas important indicated individual influence insecurity integration involved Japan Japanese Kawabata killed Kyoto lack leaders live major males means mind Mishima mother motivation natural one's orientation parents percent person prejudice Press problem produced reason regarded relations relationship responsibility samurai sense situation social society SOURCE status strong subjects success suffered suicide suicide rate superior thinking tion Tokyo traditional understanding University weak Western wish women workers writers yakuza York young youth