Divided by the Wall: Progressive and Conservative Immigration Politics at the U.S.-Mexico Border

Emine Fidan Elcioglu

Univ of California Press, Aug 4, 2020 - Social Science - 316 pages

The construction of a wall on the U.S.-Mexico border—whether to build it or not—has become a hot-button issue in contemporary America. A recent impasse over funding a wall caused the longest government shutdown in U.S. history, sharpening partisan divisions across the nation. In the Arizona borderlands, groups of predominantly white American citizens have been mobilizing for decades—some help undocumented immigrants bypass governmental detection, while others help law enforcement agents to apprehend immigrants. Activists on both the left and the right mobilize without an immediate personal connection to the issue at hand, many doubting that their actions can bring about the long-term change they desire. Why, then, do they engage in immigration and border politics so passionately?

Divided by the Wall offers a one-of-a-kind comparative study of progressive pro-immigrant activists and their conservative immigration-restrictionist opponents. Using twenty months of ethnographic research with five grassroots organizations, Emine Fidan Elcioglu shows how immigration politics has become a substitute for struggles around class inequality among white Americans. She demonstrates how activists mobilized not only to change the rules of immigration but also to experience a change in themselves. Elcioglu finds that the variation in social class and intersectional identity across the two sides mapped onto disparate concerns about state power. As activists strategized ways to transform the scope of the state’s power, they also tried to carve out self-transformative roles for themselves. Provocative and even-handed, Divided by the Wall challenges our understanding of immigration politics in times of growing inequality and insecurity.

 

Contents

• State Effects and the Politics: 1
• Arizona and the Making of an Ambiguous Border: 31
• Being Progressive but Privileged: 40
• Being White but Working Class: 70
• CONTENDING WITH CHALLENGES: 97
• The Proimmigrant Strategy: 155
• The Restrictionist Strategy: 185
• Going beyond the Wall: 219
• Methods: 235
• Notes: 257
• References: 277
• Index: 291

About the author

Emine Fidan Elcioglu is Assistant Professor of Sociology at the University of Toronto. 

Bibliographic information

• Title: Divided by the Wall: Progressive and Conservative Immigration Politics at the U.S.-Mexico Border
• Author: Emine Fidan Elcioglu
• Edition: illustrated
• Publisher: Univ of California Press, 2020
• ISBN: 0520340361, 9780520340367
• Length: 316 pages
• Subjects: Social Science / Emigration & Immigration; Social Science / Sociology / General